olymmath

SCHWEITZER 1972

Miklós Schweitzer Competition 1972.

Other problems

Problem 1

Let F\mathcal{F} be a nonempty family of sets with the following properties:

(a) If X∈FX \in \mathcal{F} , then there are some Y∈FY \in \mathcal{F} and Z∈FZ \in \mathcal{F} such that Y∩Z=∅Y \cap Z =\emptyset and Y∪Z=XY \cup Z=X .

(b) If X∈FX \in \mathcal{F} , and Y∪Z=X,Y∩Z=∅Y \cup Z =X , Y \cap Z=\emptyset , then either Y∈FY \in \mathcal{F} or Z∈FZ \in \mathcal{F} .

Show that there is a decreasing sequence X0⊇X1⊇X2⊇...X_0 \supseteq X_1 \supseteq X_2 \supseteq ... of sets Xn∈FX_n \in \mathcal{F} such that ⋂n=0∞Xn=∅.\bigcap_{n=0}^{\infty} X_n= \emptyset.

F. Galvin

Problem 2

Let ≤\leq be a reflexive, antisymmetric relation on a finite set AA . Show that this relation can be extended to an appropriate finite superset BB of AA such that ≤\leq on BB remains reflexive, antisymmetric, and any two elements of BB have a least upper bound as well as a greatest lower bound. (The relation ≤\leq is extended to BB if for x,y∈A,x≤yx,y \in A , x \leq y holds in AA if and only if it holds in BB .)

E. Freid

Problem 3

Let λi  (i=1,2,...)\lambda_i \;(i=1,2,...) be a sequence of distinct positive numbers tending to infinity. Consider the set of all numbers representable in the form μ=∑i=1∞niλi,\mu= \sum_{i=1}^{\infty}n_i\lambda_i , where ni≥0n_i \geq 0 are integers and all but finitely many nin_i are 00 . Let L(x)=∑λi≤x1  and M(x)=∑μ≤x1 .L(x)= \sum _{\lambda_i \leq x} 1 \;\textrm{and}\ M(x)= \sum _{\mu \leq x} 1 \ . (In the latter sum, each μ\mu occurs as many times as its number of representations in the above form.) Prove that if lim⁡x→∞L(x+1)L(x)=1,\lim_{x\rightarrow \infty} \frac{L(x+1)}{L(x)}=1, then lim⁡x→∞M(x+1)M(x)=1.\lim_{x\rightarrow \infty} \frac{M(x+1)}{M(x)}=1.

G. Halasz

Problem 4

Let GG be a solvable torsion group in which every Abelian subgroup is finitely generated. Prove that GG is finite.

J. Pelikan

Problem 5

We say that the real-valued function f(x)f(x) defined on the interval (0,1)(0,1) is approximately continuous on (0,1)(0,1) if for any x0∈(0,1)x_0 \in (0,1) and ε>0\varepsilon >0 the point x0x_0 is a point of interior density 11 of the set H={x:  ∣f(x)−f(x0)∣<ε }.H= \{x : \;|f(x)-f(x_0)|< \varepsilon \ \}. Let F⊂(0,1)F \subset (0,1) be a countable closed set, and g(x)g(x) a real-valued function defined on FF . Prove the existence of an approximately continuous function f(x)f(x) defined on (0,1)(0,1) such that f(x)=g(x)  for all x∈F .f(x)=g(x) \;\textrm{for all}\ x \in F\ .

M. Laczkovich, Gy. Petruska

Problem 6

Let P(z)P(z) be a polynomial of degree nn with complex coefficients, P(0)=1,  and   ∣P(z)∣≤M   for   ∣z∣≤1 .P(0)=1, \;\textrm{and}\ \;|P(z)|\leq M\ \;\textrm{for}\ \;|z| \leq 1\ . Prove that every root of P(z)P(z) in the closed unit disc has multiplicity at most cnc\sqrt{n} , where c=c(M)>0c=c(M) >0 is a constant depending only on MM .

G. Halasz

Problem 7

Let f(x,y,z)f(x,y,z) be a nonnegative harmonic function in the unit ball of R3\mathbb{R}^3 for which the inequality f(x0,0,0)≤ε2f(x_0,0,0) \leq \varepsilon^2 holds for some 0≤x0≤10\leq x_0 \leq 1 and 0<ε<(1−x0)20<\varepsilon<(1-x_0)^2 . Prove that f(x,y,z)≤εf(x,y,z) \leq \varepsilon in the ball with center at the origin an radius (1−3ε1/4).(1-3\varepsilon^{1/4}).

P. Turan

Problem 8

Given four points A1,A2,A3,A4A_1,A_2,A_3,A_4 in the plane in such a way that A4A_4 is the centroid of the △A1A2A3\bigtriangleup A_1A_2A_3 , find a point A5A_5 in the plane that maximizes the ratio min⁡1≤i<j<k≤5T(AiAjAk)max⁡1≤i<j<k≤5T(AiAjAk).\frac{\min_{1 \leq i < j < k \leq 5}T(A_iA_jA_k)}{\max_{1 \leq i < j < k \leq 5}T(A_iA_jA_k)}. ( T(ABC)T(ABC) denotes the area of the triangle △ABC.\bigtriangleup ABC. )

J. Suranyi

Problem 9

Let KK be a compact convex body in the nn -dimensional Euclidean space. Let P1,P2,...,Pn+1P_1,P_2,...,P_{n+1} be the vertices of a simplex having maximal volume among all simplices inscribed in KK . Define the points Pn+2,Pn+3,...P_{n+2},P_{n+3},... successively so that Pk  (k>n+1)P_k \;(k>n+1) is a point of KK for which the volume of the convex hull of P1,...,PkP_1,...,P_k is maximal. Denote this volume by VkV_k . Decide, for different values of nn , about the truth of the statement "the sequence Vn+1,Vn+2,...V_{n+1},V_{n+2},... is concave."

L. Fejes- Toth, E. Makai

Problem 10

Let T1\mathcal{T}_1 and T2\mathcal{T}_2 be second-countable topologies on the set EE . We would like to find a real function σ\sigma defined on E×EE \times E such that 0≤σ(x,y)<+∞,  σ(x,x)=0 ,0 \leq \sigma(x,y) <+\infty, \;\sigma(x,x)=0 \ , σ(x,z)≤σ(x,y)+σ(y,z)  (x,y,z∈E) ,\sigma(x,z) \leq \sigma(x,y)+\sigma(y,z) \;(x,y,z \in E) \ , and, for any p∈Ep \in E , the sets V1(p,ε)={x:  σ(x,p)<ε }  (ε>0)V_1(p,\varepsilon)=\{ x : \;\sigma(x,p)< \varepsilon \ \} \;(\varepsilon >0) form a neighborhood base of pp with respect to T1\mathcal{T}_1 , and the sets V2(p,ε)={x:  σ(p,x)<ε }  (ε>0)V_2(p,\varepsilon)=\{ x : \;\sigma(p,x)< \varepsilon \ \} \;(\varepsilon >0) form a neighborhood base of pp with respect to T2\mathcal{T}_2 . Prove that such a function σ\sigma exists if and only if, for any p∈Ep \in E and Ti\mathcal{T}_i -open set G∋p  (i=1,2)G \ni p \;(i=1,2) , there exist a Ti\mathcal{T}_i -open set G′G' and a T3−i\mathcal{T}_{3-i} -closed set FF with p∈G′⊂F⊂G.p \in G' \subset F \subset G.

A. Csaszar

Problem 11

We throw NN balls into nn urns, one by one, independently and uniformly. Let Xi=Xi(N,n)X_i=X_i(N,n) be the total number of balls in the ii th urn. Consider the random variable y(N,n)=min⁡1≤i≤n∣Xi−Nn∣.y(N,n)=\min_{1 \leq i \leq n}|X_i-\frac Nn|. Verify the following three statements:

(a) If n→∞n \rightarrow \infty and N/n3→∞N/n^3 \rightarrow \infty , then P(y(N,n)1nNn<x)→1−e−x2/π  for all x>0 .P \left(\frac{y(N,n)}{\frac 1n \sqrt{\frac Nn}}<x \right) \rightarrow 1-e^{-x\sqrt{2/ \pi}} \;\textrm{for all}\ x>0 \ .

(b) If n→∞n\rightarrow \infty and N/n3≤KN/n^3 \leq K ( KK constant), then for any ε>0\varepsilon > 0 there is an A>0A > 0 such that P(y(N,n)<A)>1−ε.P(y(N,n) < A) > 1-\varepsilon .

(c) If n→∞n \rightarrow \infty and N/n3→0N/n^3 \rightarrow 0 then P(y(N,n)<1)→1.P(y(N,n) < 1) \rightarrow 1.

P. Revesz